Harper's: "Displaced in the D.R.: A Country Strips 210,000 of Citizenship"

Photo by Daniel Loncarevic/iStock/ Getty Images

Photo by Daniel Loncarevic/iStock/ Getty Images

After stripping citizenship from over two hundred thousand Dominicans, many of Haitian descent, the Dominican Republic has threatened mass deportation for those who do not register with the government to obtain legal status. The threats of deportation come after years of anti-Haitian discrimination and a documented history of violence against Haitian immigrants culminating in 2013 when the Dominican Constitutional Tribunal, the nation's highest court, revoked citizenship retroactively to 1929 for all Dominicans with undocumented foreign parents even if they had been born in the Dominican Republic. The ruling, which became known as "the Sentence," effectively rendered 210,000 Dominicans stateless, most of whom are of Haitian descent. Juliana Deguis Pierre, who was one of the plaintiffs in the suit against the government that in the end backfired and led to her loss of citizenship, said the Sentence "paralyzed her life," as it meant she could not legally work, marry, open a bank account, get a driver’s license, vote, or register for high school or university. "I'm nobody in my own country," she told Harper's at the time.

In response to severe international criticism of the Sentence—including many who compared it to Hitler's stripping citizenship from Jews in Germany in the 1930s—the Dominican government issued a presidential decree for a "regularization" plan for undocumented immigrants. The plan allowed for anyone who immigrated to the Dominican Republic before October 2011 to apply for regular migratory status, and afterwards citizenship. While the plan did provide options for undocumented Dominicans to avoid deportation, critics of the plan noted the difficult obstacles in applying, including burdensome documentation requirements and the need to apply in-person at designated offices far from most Haitian communities. Those who did not apply by June 2015 would be deported.

Now that the June deadline has passed, with hundreds of thousands of undocumented immigrants still reportedly unregistered, it remains unclear if mass deportations will take place. The Dominican government has not stated if it will extend the deadline for registration, has repeatedly denied any plans for mass deportations, and has stated that as a sovereign nation it has the right to enact and enforce its own immigration policies as it sees fit.

In the meantime, many continue to speak out against the Dominican government's deportation plans. New York City Mayor Bill de Blasio spoke this past Sunday from Washington Heights, the Manhattan neighborhood with a large Dominican population. "It is clearly an illegal act," Mayor de Blasio said. "It is an immoral act. It is a racist act by the Dominican government. And it’s happening because these people are black. And it cannot be accepted."

IDNYC

Last Monday, Mayor Bill de Blasio introduced the city identification program, the largest program of its kind in the country, which will grant government-issued IDs regardless of immigration status. This free card, one of de Blasio's campaign pledges, promises to bring "peace of mind and access to City services that come from having recognized identification. IDNYC benefits every city resident, including the most vulnerable communities—the homeless, youth, the elderly, undocumented immigrants, the formerly incarcerated and others who may have difficulty obtaining other government-issued ID." The mayor said that the ID is just a "'piece of plastic, but it's going to open so many doors for our fellow New Yorkers.'"  

While the ID card is ideal for those who do not have government-issued ID, the administration also hopes to entice those who do by providing numerous benefits, including allowing the IDNYC card to serve as a library card in all five boroughs (anyone who has tried to sign up or has moved frequently around the boroughs knows how beneficial this could be), a one-year free membership to thirty-three of New York City's many leading museums, zoos, concert halls, and botanical gardens, as well as discounts for prescription drugs, gym memberships, and entertainment.

To qualify for the IDNYC card, applicants must be fourteen years or older and a NYC resident. Applicants must first make an appointment (the earliest available appointments for many of the interview sites were several months in advance), fill out an application confirming New York City residency, and then attend an in-person appointment with documents proving identity and NYC residence (for those who are not homeless). There have been many reports of long lines and delays. We tried out the system ourselves and received numerous error messages after several attempts to schedule an appointment, so the site still appears in need of improvement. The mayor denied there were any similarities with IDNYC to the ill-prepared HealthCare.gov rollout. Others have expressed privacy concerns over how the city would release and use the data obtained from those signing up for the program.

One of the first recipients of the IDNYC card was Esther Sanchez, an undocumented immigrant and mother of three from Mexico, who was invited to speak beside the mayor at the news conference, and who said: “This ID card is the key to having a more fulfilling life[.]”